Why Not
A multi-room basement club on George Street known for Scotland's only full LED room and a large outdoor garden. Premium table bookings come with queue jump and table service in private areas, making it Edinburgh's go-to for a booked table.
About Why Not
Why Not is a basement club at 14 George Street, at the St Andrew Square end of Edinburgh's New Town. It is a few minutes from Waverley station, the St Andrew Square tram stop and the bus station. Downstairs it is larger than the doorway suggests. There is a Main Room, the Vault, a large outdoor beer garden with its own late licence and DJs until 3am, and an LED room that the club bills as the only one of its kind in Scotland.
The club publishes three regular nights, all from 10:30pm to 3am. Love Wednesday is the midweek student night with cheaper drinks. Filthy Friday and Why Not Saturdays carry the weekend, with themed decor and live performers on top of the DJs. Across the rooms there are five cocktail bars, and the main space is fitted with a full club sound and lighting rig.
VIP tables are booked through the club's guest list and tables page. They include queue jump on arrival and table service all night in a private space. Listings give the dress code as smart casual.
Good to know before you go
What makes the LED room different?
It is a room built around full LED lighting, separate from the Main Room and the Vault. The club calls it the only full LED room in Scotland, and it is the room most first-time visitors look for.
Is the garden worth it in winter?
It is an open-air beer garden with a late licence, so it is used most in milder months. In colder weather it is mainly a place to step outside between rooms.
Which night should a group with a table aim for?
Filthy Friday or Why Not Saturdays. Wednesday is aimed at students and is busy but more casual.
Who answers table questions during the day?
The office is staffed seven days a week from 10am to 5pm on 0131 624 8633.
Booking a table at Why Not
How much is a table at Why Not?
Why Not sets table minimums per night and per event rather than publishing a price list. Message us with your date and group size and we'll get the current minimum from the venue.
How do I book a VIP table at Why Not?
Message us on WhatsApp with your date, group size and budget. We check availability with Why Not, confirm your table and minimum spend in writing, and send you the arrival details.
Where is Why Not?
Why Not is in New Town / George Street, Edinburgh, at 14 George Street, Edinburgh EH2 2PF.
Which nights is Why Not open?
Wed, Fri, Sat, 10:30pm–3am. Schedules change for holidays and events, so check your date with us.
Is there a booking fee?
No. VIPListed doesn't charge you a booking fee; you pay the venue's minimum spend on the night.
Nightlife in Edinburgh
Why Not is one of 2 VIP clubs we book in Edinburgh. Clubs here are busiest on Wednesday, Friday and Saturday. Check your date with us, as holiday and event weekends change opening nights. See the Edinburgh VIP guide for every club, event and price in one place.
| Club | Area | Music | Tables from |
|---|---|---|---|
| Why Not (this club) | New Town / George Street | Chart, party, R&B (themed nights) | On request |
| Shanghai | New Town / George Street | R&B, hip hop, Afrobeats | £70 |
More VIP clubs in Edinburgh
VIP events in Edinburgh
Details checked October 2026 against the venue's own channels and recent listings. Opening nights, music and minimum spends change; we confirm everything with the venue when you book.
